PDA

View Full Version : Thank You For Smoking



mouton
05-31-2006, 10:59 AM
THANK YOU FOR SMOKING
Written and Directed by Jason Reitman


Tobacco lobbyist, Nick Naylor, imparts many practical approaches to life’s many problems upon all the people he deals with. He tells people how to see things for a living and knows that they’re listening to him. No one person is perhaps listening to him more than his own son. And though Nick’s confidence might blind him into a false sense of security in life, he is not so far removed as to not know that the molding of his son’s mind is his most important job. Thus, when he tells his son that if you argue correctly then you are never wrong, it is not only the true beauty of argument but it is also a strong, decisive direction to give your son. In that moment, he is a good father and not one of the most hated faces in America. This dichotomy between person and persona is what makes Nick Naylor real and Aaron Echkart’s portrayal of Naylor, as it is guided along it’s unexpected journey by director Jason Reitman, is what makes THANK YOU FOR SMOKING a real smart comedy.

Anyone I know who has avoided seeing this film has done so because they didn’t want to see satirical look at smoking. The shame there is that this film avoids clichés whenever it can and doesn’t bother wasting its or our time positioning Naylor to learn a lesson about tobacco being bad. The lesson Naylor must learn is about pride as his is shaken during the course of the film by a disparaging piece of journalism. When life kicks you to the floor, it does not necessarily mean that everything you knew beforehand was wrong. (Ironically, the last time life did that to me is when I started smoking.) Naylor had a pretty good idea about how to make life work for him but he stopped believing in himself. And when you can’t convince yourself of something, you certainly can’t convince others. Further to the root of this hilarious film are purpose and drive. Naylor’s biggest criticism from those who know him is pointed at his choice to lobby for big tobacco. It seems an easy place to start but it negates that Naylor is good at what he does. He can argue well for those who no one else would dream to argue for. It therefore becomes an inspiration to push yourself as far as possible when you find what you’re truly good at. And once you’re doing something, you might as well do it as well as you can because at the end of the day, everyone’s got their mortgage to pay for and you can’t come back with nothing. That’s a little approach to life I learned from a smooth-talking guy named Nick Naylor.

Son of director Ivan Reitman, Jason has clearly found what he’s good at. THANK YOU FOR SMOKING is his first full-length film and it is sharp and witty. It has an energy that is infectious and a style that is both cool and hip, much in the way one sees smokers, minus the cancer, yellow teeth and bad breath. From the flashy pop-art of the opening credits shaped into cigarette packages to the usage of split screens, ironic subtitling and video, Reitman crafts a sexy, slick film that could have easily turned any of it’s viewers on to smoking. However, in perhaps what is Reitman’s most brilliant touch to this film, not one character ever lights up.

oscar jubis
06-01-2006, 10:51 AM
Originally posted by mouton
when he tells his son that if you argue correctly then you are never wrong, it is not only the true beauty of argument but it is also a strong, decisive direction to give your son. In that moment, he is a good father

I think this is outrageous, mouton. It takes moral/ethical relativism to an extreme. I'm not about to hand Naylor a parenting award on the basis of teaching his kid that any behavior can be explained away or rationalized.

My favorite scene is probably the one in which the kid comes to Naylor for homework help. Seems like teacher is trying to steer impressionable young minds to the political right by having them write a 2-page answer to: Why is the US government the best in the world?

I share your enthusiasm for Thank You For Smoking. It's a hilarious attack against the culture's knee-jerk tendency to regulate and attempt to control everything. I'm convinced I'm not the sole libertarian who loved it.

Besides the principals, the supporting cast is excellent. Standouts include Robert Duvall as King Tobacco, William H. Macy's Senator and Rob Lowe, perfectly cast as a new-age superagent.

mouton
06-02-2006, 10:44 AM
Hi Oscar ...

Outrageous, huh? I guess it's a good thing I'm not a parent. Really, I felt that his interest in imparting strong advice on his son that he feels will make him a better person and give him a stronger hand in life is what I felt made him a good father in that moment and subsequently, a more endearing character. It works for him and therefore he hopes it works for his son. I respect his desire to guide his son through life instead of allowing him to figure everything out on his own.

oscar jubis
06-10-2006, 09:45 PM
Originally posted by mouton
I guess it's a good thing I'm not a parent.

I'm sure you have many personal qualities that would make you a good parent.

his interest in imparting strong advice on his son...

If you insist in saying that "if you argue correctly you are never wrong" is "strong" advice, I'd say you're entitled to your opinion. I'd also say: some things are wrong no matter how you spin them. To teach your kid otherwise is "weak".

mouton
06-11-2006, 01:00 AM
This is what I love about this site, intelligent exchange. Thank you, you've made me see something very important.